Living in Hickory Hammock at Johns Lake: A Gated Lake Community in Winter Garden, FL

Welcome to Hickory Hammock at Johns Lake, a gated enclave in Winter Garden, FL, where heritage meets high-end living. With nearly 500 homes, this community blends the allure of Old Florida with modern luxury, making it a standout for home buyers in 2025. Whether you’re an experienced investor eyeing ROI, a long-time local seeking a legacy property, or a family craving a forever home, Hickory Hammock delivers. Here’s why this neighborhood deserves your attention, brought to you by Realtor Jakub Real Estate Radar.

A Legacy Etched in Citrus and Lakes

Hickory Hammock’s roots run deep, tied to W.B. Burch, a Carolina transplant who arrived in 1909 and shaped Winter Garden’s citrus boom. From his 17-room mansion on Johns Lake, Burch named Lake Claire for his daughter and Lake Burnett for himself, leaving a legacy that still defines this land. Today, the 2,500-acre Johns Lake and its smaller siblings offer a waterfront playground, while nature trails reveal osprey, bald eagles, and sand hill cranes amid Spanish Moss-draped oaks. For locals, it’s a nod to the area’s agricultural soul; for investors, it’s a rare blend of history and market appeal.

Homes That Command Attention

Hickory Hammock’s housing lineup is as diverse as it is impressive. Single-family homes and townhomes abound, with lakefront properties featuring private docks—prime for boating or resale value. The crown jewel? Emerald Pointe, an exclusive pocket of 28 spacious waterfront homes that redefine luxury. As of April 2025, prices range from $699,900 to $1,195,000, positioning Hickory Hammock as a premium yet accessible investment. Think 5-bedroom estates or serene retreats—perfect for families or portfolio builders.

Home Type	Standout Features	Price Range (2025)
Single-Family Homes	Lakefront views, private docks	$699,900 - $1,195,000
Townhomes	Amenity-rich, community-driven	Within listed range
Emerald Pointe	Elite waterfront lots, privacy	Top-tier pricing

Amenities That Rival Resorts

Hickory Hammock isn’t just a place to live—it’s a lifestyle. The zero-entry pool with shaded pergolas is a social hub, while the 24/7 fitness center boasts Matrix equipment and free weights up to 50 pounds—ideal for fitness buffs. Tennis courts with windscreen wraps, a sand volleyball court, and a kids’ soccer park cater to active residents, and the dog park splits into small and large zones with oak-shaded benches. Add in playgrounds, parks, and a community pier, and you’ve got amenities that impress even the most discerning buyer. The clubhouse, managed by Artemis Lifestyles, doubles as an event space and private rental venue—complete with a catering kitchen.

A Community That Thrives

For long-term locals, Hickory Hammock feels familiar yet elevated. Year-round events—think poolside bashes or nature walks—forge bonds, while volunteer committees and an elected board keep the community humming. Investors will note the strong HOA governance and engaged residents, signaling stability and sustained property values. It’s a neighborhood where history meets heart.

Location: Seclusion Meets Strategy

Perched on Johns Lake’s southeastern shore, Hickory Hammock offers tranquility without isolation. Winter Garden Village is a short hop for upscale shopping and dining, while State Road 429 and the Florida Turnpike put Disney World, Universal Studios, and Downtown Orlando just 20 minutes away. For commuters, it’s a dream; for investors, it’s a goldmine—proximity to Orlando’s growth corridor ensures long-term appreciation.

Schools That Set the Bar

Families—and savvy investors eyeing rental demand—will appreciate the Orange County Public Schools advantage. Whispering Oak Elementary ranks in Florida’s top 5%, with 79% math proficiency and 82% reading proficiency, a magnet for education-driven buyers. Sunridge Middle and West Orange High uphold the district’s reputation, making Hickory Hammock a family-friendly win with resale potential.

2025 Market Edge

Winter Garden’s market is heating up in 2025, and Hickory Hammock is perfectly positioned. Increased inventory across the region, fueled by new construction, could soften prices—yet this community’s premium offerings hold steady at $699,900 to $1,195,000. For investors, it’s a sweet spot: luxury demand meets a buyer-friendly shift. Long-term locals know Winter Garden’s growth trajectory; this is your chance to secure a piece of it before the next boom.

Why Hickory Hammock Stands Out

Hickory Hammock at Johns Lake isn’t just a neighborhood—it’s an investment in lifestyle and legacy. Lakefront living, top-tier amenities, and a tight-knit community come wrapped in a gated package that balances seclusion and connectivity. For the experienced investor, it’s a proven performer with upside potential. For the Winter Garden native, it’s a modern echo of the town’s storied past.